Nautilus with moonphase and power reserve at a comparable secondary price to the 5711, offering substantially more complication.
The 5712A moon phase is one of the most liquid Nautilus references; strong collector demand and limited production keep secondary prices well above retail across all dial colors.
The 5712/1A-001 packs moon phase, power reserve indicator, and date into the 40mm steel Nautilus case without looking overloaded , a genuine engineering feat given the dial real estate. Collectors who find the 5711 too restrained come here for complexity, and the integrated display at 6 o'clock pulls it off with unusual coherence. Steel, complications, and an in-production reference: the secondary market reflects exactly that combination.
Patek introduced the 5712 in 2006 as the first Nautilus to carry a triple complication, powered by the 240 PS IRM C LU , a peripheral-rotor automatic with moon phase, power reserve, and date modules layered on the 240 base caliber. The reference has been in continuous production since launch, with steel on the bracelet (5712/1A-001) as the entry point alongside subsequent launches in rose gold (5712R) and white gold (5712G). No significant dial generation change has altered the fundamental layout; minor finishing refinements have occurred over the years but nothing that creates meaningful vintage-versus-current arbitrage within the steel reference.
The 40mm case diameter is shared with the core Nautilus lineup, keeping proportions in line with the 5711 despite the additional movement height.
Moon phase discs are delicate: inspect the disc surface under magnification for chips, fading, or misalignment , replacing a damaged disc is a specialty job and not cheap. Power reserve displays on well-used examples sometimes show a sticky or inaccurate read; ask the seller for a full wind and a documented run-down before purchase. The bracelet on pre-2015 examples tends to show more stretch than equivalent 5711 bracelets of the same age because the 5712 skews toward buyers who wear it daily as a single watch.
Confirm all original paperwork specifies 5712/1A-001 exactly; early grey-market listings have occasionally muddled 5712 sub-references. Any service history should note caliber-specific complication work, not just a generic movement service.
The 5712/1A-001 trades at a meaningful premium over the 5711/1A-010 in the secondary market , typically 20-35% higher on comparable condition examples , reflecting the complication surcharge on top of the base Nautilus demand. Current retail is in the $55,000-$60,000 range; secondary market for clean examples with box and papers has been running $85,000-$110,000 depending on year and condition, with pre-owned dealer asking prices often higher. The premium compresses slightly when the broader Nautilus market softens because the 5712 buyer pool is narrower than the 5711's.
Unpapered examples take a sharper discount here than on simpler Nautilus references, given that complication provenance matters to buyers doing due diligence.
The 240 PS IRM C LU is a sophisticated movement and Patek recommends a full service every 3-5 years for watches worn regularly, though low-wear examples often run longer between services without issue. A full factory service , movement disassembly, complication module work, case and bracelet refinishing , runs $2,500-$4,000 at an authorized service center; complication-specific parts replacement can push that higher. Budget for service costs when buying a used example that cannot document recent work.
Community + OSINT signals haven’t landed for this reference yet. We don’t publish a rating against zero signal — the number would mean nothing. Editorial body + caliber + market value still surface above; ratings appear once the signal corpus does.
The Nautilus 5712/1A combines the most recognized sport-watch case in high horology with an in-house annual calendar. High-quality fakes target the steel/blue dial variant specifically.
| Area | What to check | What is correct | Red flag |
|---|---|---|---|
| dial | Horizontal stripe embossed texture | Identical embossed pattern to the 5711; crisp, even ridges that are tactile and cast shadow under directional light; consistent edge-to-edge | Flat or printed texture simulation; ridges that fade near the date windows or moonphase aperture |
| dial | Annual calendar apertures and moonphase disc | Day, date, and month displayed in dedicated windows; moonphase disc through the lower aperture shows correct disc color and star count for genuine Patek specification | Window borders that are uneven or misaligned; moonphase disc with incorrect star pattern or background color inconsistent with known production examples |
The 5712/1A combines the most recognized sport-watch case in high horology with an in-house annual calendar and moonphase. Replica quality is improving; the annuaire calendar function and moonphase disc specifics are the strongest verification points.
Editorial estimate. Actual prices vary by condition, date, and box/papers status. Live pricing data is in development.
| movement | Cal. 324 S QA LU annual calendar mechanism | Cal. 324 S QA LU features the Patek annual calendar mechanism that auto-corrects for months of 30 and 31 days; moonphase deviation is under one day per 122 years; Geneva seal visible on bridges | Non-Patek annual calendar mechanism; absence of Geneva seal; calendar that requires manual correction for 30-day months |
| case | Porthole octagonal bezel integration | Eight-sided bezel integrates flush with the rounded case flanks; polished bevels and brushed panels alternate correctly; no gap at the bezel-to-bracelet junction | Visible step at bezel-to-case junction; bevels eroded by polishing; octagonal geometry with incorrect lug proportions |
| bracelet | Integrated Nautilus bracelet finishing | Brushed center links with polished edges; bracelet tapers toward the Patek folding clasp; clasp engraving in correct PP typeface | Center links with incorrect brushing direction; bracelet that does not taper correctly; clasp typography inconsistent with Patek production standard |
| caseback | Exhibition caseback with movement view | Clear display caseback; Cal. 324 S QA LU visible with Patek finishing; caseback engraved with reference 5712/1A and serial on case flank | Non-Patek movement visible; caseback in incorrect Patek typeface; serial inconsistent with known 5712 production |
